The review for this task
Can a GEO tool tell you how to change your site so AI mentions you more?
GEO tools · scores
ChatGPT led all three tasks; the five GEO tools split on diagnosis and actions
Composite out of 100 = 0.30 questions + 0.30 diagnosis + 0.40 actions, from unrounded values. Hollow marks: the three task scores.
CompositeQuestionsDiagnosisActions
1ChatGPTrecorded label Astra GPT-670.1Best
2Writesonic50.3
3Peec AI40.6
4Otterly34.1
5Scrunch21.9
6Profound19.1
Score out of 1000255075100
Could swap: excluding actions puts Otterly above Peec AI; dropping one brand (OpusClip) puts Profound above Scrunch.
- A zero on actions means no usable action was delivered within the test window; it counts as a failure on that task. The products got there in different recorded states.
- The composite is a weighting of the three measured tasks, not a verdict on the whole platform.
- BEST marks the best result on each measure; ties are marked equally.
6 products × 9 brands · equal weight per brand · AI-assisted scoringanalyst.ai
ChatGPT ranked first at all nine brands (composite 70.1/100); among the dedicated tools only Peec AI produced actions that met our standard. ChatGPT’s prompt matched the scoring rules, and an OpenAI system judged its outputs.